Rare 1996 Songwriters Roundtable: Ray Davies, Don McLean, Larry LeBlanc & Jose Feliciano

In this spectacular and historically priceless October 1996 broadcast of The Dini Petty Show, television audiences were treated to an incredibly rare cultural event: a unified, long-form roundtable featuring three legendary masters of 20th-century songwriting. Gathered around a single table in Toronto, Ray Davies of The Kinks (“You Really Got Me,” “Lola”), folk-rock titan Don McLean (“American Pie,” “Vincent”), and virtuoso Latin pioneer Jose Feliciano (“Feliz Navidad,” “Light My Fire”) sit side-by-side. Joined by Billboard magazine’s veteran Canadian editor Larry LeBlanc, these three giants from entirely distinct musical traditions dissect the elusive, unpredictable, and deeply personal craft of creating timeless art.

The dynamic between the three songwriters is electric, instantly shifting from poignant creative reflection to sharp, good-natured banter. The generational and stylistic divide sparks early on when Don McLean candidly admits that “modern music depresses me,” confessing that the rising tide of 1990s hip-hop and rap culture simply doesn’t connect with him. What follows is a legendary piece of late-90s television history: the witty and rebellious Ray Davies immediately starts playfully rapping across the table at McLean to defend the evolving genre. The table rallies together, however, to passionately defend the foundational rock-and-roll genius of pioneers like Little Richard, debating what elements of modern sound still possess the power to excite them.

When host Dini Petty pushes the panel on how they actually capture their iconic tunes, the legendary artists reveal vastly different creative processes. While Feliciano beautifully explains that his most haunting melodies arrive to him fully formed in his dreams, Davies speaks to the agonizing, split-second focus required to “catch” a song out of thin air before it vanishes. However, the emotional climax of the roundtable occurs when McLean drops a brutally honest, one-line answer regarding his practical inspiration for writing that leaves the entire room—including his fellow legends—momentarily stunned and unable to recover.

With surviving footage of this iconic trio together being vanishingly rare, this broadcast captures a monumental meeting of musical minds at their most relaxed and candid. Unseen since its original mid-90s CTV airing, this pristine master tape has been meticulously optimized and preserved via the official archive of The Dini Petty Show, protecting an invaluable educational resource and a joyous celebration of musical genius.

Episodes Available for Licensing